Saturday, December 20, 2008

Bad Policy Kills


It’s estimated that Soviet Russia’s government killed at least 20 million of its own citizens. Higher estimates are triple that around 60 million, lower estimates are around 7 million. 6 million Jews are thought to have died in the holocaust, and yet holocaust victims are given infinitely more memorials and museums than Soviet Russia’s. Part of this is in response to the sheer idea of the planned genocide of a whole race – no doubt one of the ugliest marks on Western civilization. Post World War II saw dramatic improvements but only in some areas: US and England experienced one of their largest growth eras. And yet in the decade after the war, Russia saw around a quarter to a third of those mass Russian deaths.




We tuck away in history the bits and pieces that we want to ignore while other bits and pieces continue to have meaning today. Modern-day Nazi’s are despised as murderous racists while communists are simply considered harmless liberal extremes. But “it works in theory” I hear from some of my friends. Yet so does Nazism, which is as steeped in its own ideas as any other ideology. Any theory works in theory; if it didn't it would cease to be a theory and then it would be something else. To advocate communism without addressing areas in which its lead to widespread starvation and death - Russia being just one example - is like advocating Nazism without addressing the holocaust.

The extremes of where an idea have gone wrong are often most telling, but you have to look within extremes as well: Extremist ideas, many have argued, aren't always categorically different from their watered down counterparts. Consider
  • Communism in the extreme has led to mass starvation, but in the less extreme it's bad health care.
  • Nazism in the extreme was the holocaust, but in the less extreme it was Kristallnacht.
  • Discrimination in the extreme led to lynchings, while in the less extreme it led to segregation.
  • Religious fanaticism in the extreme is seen as terrorism, while in the less extreme it's evangelical Christianity.
Moderate ideas from one culture sound radical to another. While the outcomes of such extremist movements are alarming, we are doing ourselves a disservice by separating ourselves from them, rather than trying to discern historically where they came from. The holocaust was terrible, but Nazi's are people too. What part of human nature - the very same human nature that yes we all share - had gone wrong? Looking at the roots of many extremist movements in the world, we can see many of our own commonly held moderate ideas, and their drawn out implications.

Not to sound polarizing, it’s just surprising how we cling so readily to some atrocities while completely disregarding others. Europe circa WWII is a very concrete example, as both Nazi and Soviet atrocities occurred in the same era and in the same part of the world. And this is by no means a mere abstract question, we’re dealing with two independent events responsible each for over 6 million deaths. Yet how often do you hear, "Remember the Soviet Union and its millions of victims"? My suspicion is that we’re less likely to recall the deaths in Soviet Russia because communism, moreso than Nazism, is somewhat accepted in America, particularly among liberals.

People cling to their opinions as their personal identity. As Tocqueville pointed out, this is a natural byproduct of democracy and freedom of speech. Ideas suddenly separate people, and they have concrete manifestations. Opinionated as I may seem, I really try to hold them at an arm’s length from my mind.

Sometimes I’ll go to social events with “intellectual conversations” where people will say things like “I believe that all people should earn equal incomes” or “I think education is important”, note with the emphasis more on the first person than on the opinion itself. It’s indeed correct that the first person, I, deserves emphasis, it is more important than the opinion itself. But unfortunately the manifest content of the discussion is inevitably on the issue being discussed not the person talking. And in this context, something like “I think education is important” is one of the the weakest arguments. What people fail to realize – I think sometimes to a fault – is that opinions are easy. They’re cheap. And granted this is just my opinion as well, but they’re often fairly meaningless.

Opinions again can be very personal while the real world is anything but. To get the one confused for the other is a very confusing state indeed. Should I ever come across such concrete evidence as to truly undermine my own opinions about the world, then I hope that I have the strength and peace of mind to change how I view the world.

Some people say that the best politics is always personal. But I just don’t buy it. Because the personal is referring to you - how you feel - and the politics is reflected in reality. It's like saying that physics should always be personal - a colossal confusion between the subjective and objective. And no it's not that politics deals with things that are more personal than physics, as I'm sure some physicists would tell you that physics is more personal. It's that reality abides by laws - such as economics laws - much sooner than it abides by our personal preferences. Contrary to the notion of personal politics, passion and fury when it's coming from a politician is ultimately no more persuasive than when it's coming from a crazy scientist. Distinguishment for the most passionate and fiery politician might very well go to Hitler with his unmatched ability to rile crowds and to gather a whole nation behind him. Personal politics isn’t necessarily opposite of good politics, but they are often placed at odds. The disconnect between personal politics and good politics is like that between the short-term solution and the long-term solution; between the irrational and the rational; between a rash emotional decision and a carefully thought out one. Which isn’t to say that good politics can’t be personal – ultimately all these distinctions are artificial – but it is to say that that which is personal isn’t categorically better. Often it’s worse.

When reality doesn’t match people’s opinions, they often think that it’s the world that has to change. Anything but.

-KJ

_______________
Media (in order of appearance)

Photo: (1) CCCP, 04/07/2008, by MrOmega; (2) At the Temple, 02/05/2007, by Pete4Ducks; (3) She's made up her mind, 10/12/2008, by bobster1985; (4) Del Martin, 1966, 10/20/2008, also by bobster1985; (5) Hong Kong in Motion, 09/16/2006, by Steve Webel.

Video: (1) Tv Theme World At War, 10/05/2008, tvtestcard's channel from the 1973/1974 documentary series World at War.
Sphere: Related Content

Thursday, December 18, 2008

Piece of Fiction: Day at a Time

Here's another piece of fiction, a vignette. It's loosely based on one of my mornings a month or 2 ago, and then recently committed to paper during - for the better or worse like some other posts - a boring speech at a conference.

________________________

10am he stepped out the house door to wind-swept streets. He’d overslept, but the extra hours of sleep they inspired a calm rather than a hurry. He walked two blocks briefcase steady in hand to his parked car. Fallen leaves rustled in a breeze, subtly refreshing, their dull color further blunted by a thin morning fog. The curvy suburban street lay motionless and eerie, cars at rest along tall slanted tree lines. He was acutely aware of his hair, how his bangs they shifted along his forehead and atop his ears, this from the extra sleep.

His navy car was parked alone around a corner. To his surprise a thin and inconsistent layer of mud stuck to the exterior. The dried dirt was new he hadn’t seen it before. Perhaps it was the wind overnight? Delaying briefly his commute the man walked around the car. Dirt was on all sides. He looked up focused on his surroundings, wondering if he had missed something in his extra hours of sleep that seemed to produce an aesthetic high, but it wasn’t clear if it leaned towards intoxication or sobriety. What had I missed?, he thought as he opened his car door, scratching some dry mud. Still he hadn’t seen a soul on the street, nor a moving car nor any signs of life. What’s happened?

He drove the same route he did every morning, around curves tucked under trees, over short hills studded with old houses, around bends with limited view – a path he knew as well as the lines on his palm, a drive he could navigate in his sleep which seemed as inevitable as life itself. Still, the bigger roads were just as empty as the smaller ones and this he pondered with the small piece of mind he afforded it, but he couldn’t help but notice the fleeting feeling that time its very essence seemed to stand still.

1025am he turned into his work’s parking garage and funneled around the poorly lit concrete labyrinth until he found an empty spot for his newly grunged up car. Still yet again not a soul nor even a moving car. He turned off the ignition. Flipped off the headlights. Straining in his seat to pocket his keys, he noticed the red backlights finally of a passing car behind him. He looked at himself in the rearview mirror, and raising a hand I combed my fingers through my hair looking forward animatedly to another day.

-KJ Sphere: Related Content

Tuesday, December 16, 2008

"Financial psychopaths wreak havoc."

I try to keep an open mind specifically in spite of my opinions. Capitalism works, but scandals like the Madoff one do test my so called "faith". Forbes went so far as to call Madoff a financial psychopath in response to his peculiarly candid admission of guilt. What if, I think, one quarter of all CEO’s turn out to be engaged in scandal? Then again, politicians aren't perfect either, and giving them more money only shifts and centralizes responsibility. But what if the average human, given high enough earnings, can’t help but let money get to his mind? This happened to me once at a casino. Allow, reader, for a personal anecdote followed by a return to larger issues at hand.

A friend and I once visited a casino pledging to each other that we would only bring $100, spend it on Blackjack using basic strategy, and double down after each loss. We’d spent a few weeks memorizing basic strategy, which is a set of established pre-determined decisions that minimize the house’s advantage to just over one percent. And then doubling-down on each loss means that you double your ante after each hand that you lose. So if you lose on a one-dollar hand, you bet two dollars; if you lose again, then four; eight, etc. Beginning with a minimum bet of $5, it only takes six consecutive losses before you find yourself betting $160. Then again, when or if you finally win, you regain your losses plus a hefty percent. Nonetheless, things add up quickly when you double-down. Although your odds are almost fifty-fifty with basic strategy, you can easily lose more than six times in a row if you play long enough. But that’s why went in with a pact. This way we wouldn’t chicken out. Worse case scenario, we leave after 30 minutes and cut our losses.

Funny thing, we started winning. At first it just felt like dumb-luck. Then it continued. The minimum bet was $5, but after breaking a few short strings of losses, your average winnings per hand becomes much more than $5 – assuming, of course, that you still have the money to double down with. Independently we each approached scary bets - $80, $160 - that threatened to be our last. But we reminded ourselves of our agreement, fortune smiled upon us, and we’d find ourselves with $320 dollars instead of zero. The pit-bosses were eying us with suspicion, and when we each had around $500 we had to take a break. We returned and the winnings kept adding up, until I had around $1000 and my friend had much more.

Eventually reality set in as forcefully as it had stepped out. As we started losing, we got nervous, we each veered away from the strategy, got burned by it, started again, and got burned some more. Degrading smiles replaced the pit-bosses’ suspicion. I left with $200, my friend left with none. When I tell the story friends often ask why I didn't just leave with $1000. I tell them that's precisely missing the point, because if I was thinking rationally, I wouldn't have been in there in the first place.

This 6-hour roller-coaster of an experience changed how I viewed the world. Sometime in the middle, I distinctly recall reaching a point where nothing made sense anymore. Here was this thing money - its intrinsic value I never thought of much - that you work so hard for, and all the sudden, it’s falling out of the sky. I was shaking, palms sweaty, simply trying to keep my growing number of chips in neat piles. You lose a nerve-racking $160 bet and think that was stupid, but then you’d gain twice that on the next one. In a very fundamental way, the walls of reality began to melt, as if I was on hallucinogenics.

Does a similar thing happen to CEO’s? The worry is that you begin making an incredible amount of money, then only attribute your gains to things you do, when it really might just be market-conditions or lady-luck dealing you a good hand. Of course, success isn't all due to luck, but it still plays a big factor. Contrary to our thoughts at the time, my friend and I hadn't found the secret to earning tons of money, we'd merely been dealt a few good hands. Nonetheless, you can find yourself feeling indestructible, beyond rationality and rules, when that's clearly not the case. This is essentially what happened to The Smartest Guys in the Room who raised and crashed Enron. It wouldn't be far off to call them megalomaniac gamblers. They openly embraced risk as a business strategy.

At the same time, it’s easy to overlook how the alternative – socialism, communism – contains at least the same risk of public scandal, if not more. Political scandals are arguably more frequent than financial ones. By keeping politics separate from too much capital, at least to the degree possible, we can isolate such incidents.

Financial scandals still contain a distinctly different feel than political ones. A political scandal may kill an individual’s career, but little fundamentally changes except for, perhaps, a few more people now see politics as dirty. Financial scandals, on the other hand, are weightier. They affect more people’s daily lives, as economics is fundamentally more powerful than politics. They also turn into liberal cannon-fodder for an end to free-market capitalism. But once again, I'm not sure how giving more money to politicians is any better.

It’s an irony of our government that we try to succeed in unnecessary undertakings while failing in very basic areas. When approved drugs turn out to be dangerous, the FDA (who already have an impossibly difficult job) gets more money; but when Wall Street steals money, the SEC receives little public scrutiny, and, at the most, legislates a few new rules. The Forbes article on Madoff does a good job in placing some blame on the SEC, who rightly received similar criticism after the Enron scandal. All too often, however, the SEC's response is new legislation and rules, not better policing or detective-work. New rules that only pave the way for people to look for new ways to break them. People go astray all the time. We need to catch them.

The experience at the casino taught me about the misery of the gambler, a play on a theme of the sort of people who drive down seemingly indestructible companies like Enron. Similar I'd imagine to breaking the law, when you first get away with gambling you feel lucky; when you do it again, you might feel empowered; and when you keep doing it, and keep raising the stakes, you feel indestructible...until, of course, your inevitable downfall. Of course there's a rational part of you that knows this is wrong, just as Madoff knew unquestionably that he was wrongfully breaking the law. When you disregard rationality, life’s aspirations are suddenly right next to its underbelly. It draws a thin line between heaven and hell, placing you short-term in the former, long-term in the latter. Left in its natural state and allowed to fend only for itself, gambling’s predominant outcome is complete utter failure. All the more reason to decentralize capital.

-KJ
_____________
Media (in order of appearance):

Photo: (1) Bernard_L_Madoff, 12/15/2008, marclsudo; (2) compulsive, 04/01/2005, by fictures; (3) someone has to win., 09/23/2007, by austrini; (4) Morning gamblers at Whiskey Pete's, 04/01/2007, by CFBSr; (5) BALLY'S WALKWAY, 08/23/2005, by snowriderguy; (6) Extra, 05/25/2006, by Alex Steffler; (7) Dice, 09/28/2005, by RobW.
Sphere: Related Content
 
Add to Technorati Favorites Add to Technorati Favorites